Your Neighborhood Pizzeria in York, PA
Whether you’re stopping in for a family dinner or a quick lunch, every meal is a reminder of what good food and community taste like.
Fresh Dough
Rich Tomato Sauce
Premium Cheese
A Local Pizzeria Bringing Abbottstown’s Flavor to York
Locals have celebrated the original Donatello’s Pizzeria & Grille in Abbottstown for years, and now that same beloved flavor has arrived in York. Known for its handcrafted pizzas, generous toppings, and welcoming atmosphere, this new location carries on a tradition of quality and comfort. Every pizza is baked to perfection using fresh dough, rich tomato sauce, and premium cheese that melts beautifully in every bite. Whether you’re stopping in for a family dinner or a quick lunch, every meal is a reminder of what good food and community taste like.
Menu Highlights
From Hot Pizzas to Hearty Meals at Your Local Pizzeria
Pizza might be the centerpiece, but the menu offers much more than what comes out of the oven. Guests can choose from an incredible variety of hot and cold subs, juicy burgers, wraps, strombolis, and pasta dinners made with authentic Italian flavor. Our team prepares every dish to order with the same dedication to freshness that defines this local pizzeria.. Customers love pairing their meals with crispy fries, golden onion rings, or one of the house salads made with fresh romaine and toppings. There are also daily and weekly specials that make every visit something new to look forward to.
York’s Pizzeria for Comfort, Community, and Classic Taste
This neighborhood spot brings people together over classic comfort food and genuine hospitality. With easy online ordering, fast service, and curbside pickup, Donatello’s 2 makes enjoying your favorite pizza and sides simple and stress-free. Families, coworkers, and students across York are discovering why this pizzeria is quickly becoming their go-to for delicious meals at fair prices. From the first slice of a hot pizza to the last bite of dessert, every visit feels like coming home to flavor you can count on.
Customer Review
Small business, Some of the best pizza around! Good service, nice people, always a great experience.
Taste the Best of York’s Pizzeria Tradition
Experience what locals have loved for years—authentic Italian flavor, generous portions, and friendly service all under one roof. Stop by for dine-in, call ahead for takeout, or order online for convenient curbside pickup. Every bite captures the warmth, flavor, and pride that make this pizzeria a true local legend across Pennsylvania.
This small pizza shop sits back off the road on RT 30 between Abbottstown and Crosskeys. Today they had a daily special of any sub and fries and a drink for 10.99. This is a great value. The menu consists of pizza subs, stromboli, and some pasta dishes. And of course wings.Service here was polite, and fast . The sub I had seemed to have decent ingredients. It was very good. Still could have used a little more seasoning.They make their own pizza dough and sub rolls.Their dining area does have a TV and refillable sodas. I would come back here just on the value. And I do recommend you trying this place. At least their subs.